Flock Exposed - Built for the Next Lockdown

Critics across the political spectrum warn that the real danger of Flock's camera network isn't how it's being used today - it's how it could be used tomorrow. That includes a future public health emergency, whether it's called a pandemic, an epidemic, or something else entirely. A nationwide, AI-powered system that already logs every passing vehicle would be a ready-made tool for enforcing a future stay-at-home order, quarantine, or travel restriction.

Source: The Libertarian Institute, "You Should Feel Good About the Flock Debate"

It Already Happened Once, on a Smaller Scale

During the COVID-19 pandemic, officers in Kentucky recorded the license plates of churchgoers attending drive-in Easter services specifically to issue them quarantine notices. In California, paddleboarders were chased down by health authorities for being outside during lockdown. Neither state had anything close to Flock's nationwide, AI-searchable camera network at the time - they did it with far less capability than exists today.

Source: Washington Examiner, "Pro-Flock conservatives ignore the potential for state tyranny"

Governors Are Drawing the Same Conclusion

Florida Governor Ron DeSantis has pointed directly to this scenario in explaining why his administration is pulling Flock cameras off state roads: "If they had had all these cameras during COVID, New York, California, Biden, they would have tried to use them to enforce lockdowns. They would have used them to enforce vax mandates, and vax passports." He added a warning about the underlying business model, saying the real money a camera company makes "is by selling your data and making a fortune off that."

Source: Florida Politics, "Ron DeSantis vows to clear Flock cameras from state right-of-ways"

A Warning From the Right, Aimed at the Right

Some conservative commentators are directing this same warning at their own political allies, arguing that supporting a mass license-plate-reader dragnet requires "total amnesia" about how quickly emergency government power can be misused - pointing to the COVID era as the clearest recent example of how fast an "emergency" justification can expand.

Source: Washington Examiner, "Pro-Flock conservatives ignore the potential for state tyranny"

This Is a Future Problem, Not Just a COVID Problem

None of this is limited to the last pandemic. Flock's network doesn't expire when one public health emergency ends - the cameras, the retention policies, and the search tools stay in place, ready to be pointed at whatever the next declared emergency happens to be. A system built and normalized today is a system available to whoever holds emergency powers during the next one, regardless of party.

Questions to Ask Your Town

  • Does your town's Flock contract or local ordinance place any limit on using camera data to enforce a public health order, quarantine, or travel restriction?

  • Who would decide to activate that use, and would residents be told before it happened?

  • Has your town considered what happens to this system's capabilities the next time a governor or health department declares an emergency?

 

This page will be updated as more factual sources become available.